#101
Holmes-Simmons, Theresa
Pending
- Total Decisions
- 3670
- Asylum Grant Rate
- 57.6%
- Denial Rate
- 42.4%
- Other Relief Rate
- 0.0%
Immigration Judges with the Highest Asylum Grant Rates
This ranking is based on public asylum decision data currently compiled by ImmJudge. Historical grant rates do not predict the outcome of any individual case.
| Rank | Immigration Judge | Court | Total Decisions | Asylum Grant Rate | Denial Rate | Other Relief Rate | Sample Size Note | View details |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| #101 | Holmes-Simmons, Theresa | Pending | 3670 | 57.6% | 42.4% | 0.0% | Larger sample | View details |
| #102 | Sady, Michael | Boston | 262 | 57.6% | 42.4% | 0.0% | Larger sample | View details |
| #103 | Leadbetter, Philip P. | Pending | 1689 | 57.4% | 42.6% | 0.0% | Larger sample | View details |
| #104 | Slavin, Denise N. | Pending | 3605 | 57.1% | 42.9% | 0.0% | Larger sample | View details |
| #105 | Koppenhofer, Andrea | Miami | 416 | 57.0% | 43.0% | 0.0% | Larger sample | View details |
| #106 | McDermott, William | Philadelphia | 802 | 56.9% | 43.1% | 0.0% | Larger sample | View details |
| #107 | McFarland, Michael G | Miami | 1628 | 56.7% | 43.3% | 0.0% | Larger sample | View details |
| #108 | O'Malley, Brenda | Pending | 2238 | 56.5% | 43.5% | 0.0% | Larger sample | View details |
| #109 | Lyons, Joren | Portland | 1189 | 56.4% | 43.6% | 0.0% | Larger sample | View details |
| #110 | Dandelet, Kyle | Miami | 1108 | 56.1% | 43.9% | 0.0% | Larger sample | View details |
| #111 | Rohan, Patricia A. | Pending | 8755 | 56.1% | 43.9% | 0.0% | Larger sample | View details |
| #112 | Gonzalez, Alberto E. | Pending | 1642 | 56.0% | 44.0% | 0.0% | Larger sample | View details |
| #113 | Levay, Dean A. | Pending | 286 | 55.9% | 44.1% | 0.0% | Larger sample | View details |
| #114 | Rey Caldas, Carmen | Miami | 286 | 55.9% | 44.1% | 0.0% | Larger sample | View details |
| #115 | Patti, Sebastian T | Laredo | 897 | 55.9% | 44.1% | 0.0% | Larger sample | View details |
| #116 | Alexander, Erin | Sterling | 328 | 55.8% | 44.2% | 0.0% | Larger sample | View details |
| #117 | Proctor, George W. | Pending | 565 | 55.8% | 44.3% | 0.0% | Larger sample | View details |
| #118 | Poczter, Aviva L | Miami | 3561 | 55.6% | 44.4% | 0.0% | Larger sample | View details |
| #119 | Phan, Susan | Sacramento | 2250 | 55.5% | 44.5% | 0.0% | Larger sample | View details |
| #120 | Billings, Lucy | Miami | 295 | 55.3% | 44.8% | 0.0% | Larger sample | View details |
| #121 | Zuniga, Bertha A. | Pending | 817 | 55.2% | 44.8% | 0.0% | Larger sample | View details |
| #122 | Knuck, Richard H. | Pending | 299 | 55.2% | 44.8% | 0.0% | Larger sample | View details |
| #123 | Snow, Thomas G | Arlington | 2000 | 54.8% | 45.2% | 0.0% | Larger sample | View details |
| #124 | Gambill, Scott D | Sacramento | 1288 | 54.5% | 45.5% | 0.0% | Larger sample | View details |
| #125 | Star, Shadee M | Sacramento | 1260 | 54.4% | 45.6% | 0.0% | Larger sample | View details |
| #126 | Feder, Robin E | Honolulu | 1870 | 54.3% | 45.7% | 0.0% | Larger sample | View details |
| #127 | Munoz, Jeffrey V | Imperial | 461 | 54.2% | 45.8% | 0.0% | Larger sample | View details |
| #128 | Trujillo, Eileen R | Denver | 995 | 53.8% | 46.2% | 0.0% | Larger sample | View details |
| #129 | Rosche, Robin J | Chicago | 790 | 53.7% | 46.3% | 0.0% | Larger sample | View details |
| #130 | Dornell, Lisa | Pending | 3889 | 53.7% | 46.3% | 0.0% | Larger sample | View details |
| #131 | Burr, Sarah M. | Pending | 4532 | 53.6% | 46.4% | 0.0% | Larger sample | View details |
| #132 | Elstein, Annette S. | Pending | 5559 | 53.5% | 46.5% | 0.0% | Larger sample | View details |
| #133 | Weiss, Irene | Pending | 1490 | 53.1% | 46.9% | 0.0% | Larger sample | View details |
| #134 | Kirchner, Steven M | Sacramento | 1549 | 52.9% | 47.1% | 0.0% | Larger sample | View details |
| #135 | Figueroa, Laura C | Sacramento | 1140 | 52.8% | 47.2% | 0.0% | Larger sample | View details |
| #136 | Harbeck, Dorothy A | Miami | 1967 | 52.6% | 47.4% | 0.0% | Larger sample | View details |
| #137 | Stender, Jacob J | Sacramento | 542 | 52.6% | 47.4% | 0.0% | Larger sample | View details |
| #138 | Wilson, Roberta A | Concord | 564 | 52.5% | 47.5% | 0.0% | Larger sample | View details |
| #139 | Webber, Polly A. | Pending | 2728 | 52.3% | 47.7% | 0.0% | Larger sample | View details |
| #140 | Gover, Erin | Boston | 729 | 52.3% | 47.7% | 0.0% | Larger sample | View details |
| #141 | Gagnon, Paul M. | Pending | 1442 | 52.1% | 47.9% | 0.0% | Larger sample | View details |
| #142 | Crawford, Carol A | Miami | 767 | 52.0% | 48.0% | 0.0% | Larger sample | View details |
| #143 | Joyce, William | Pending | 639 | 52.0% | 48.0% | 0.0% | Larger sample | View details |
| #144 | Hong, J. Traci | Pending | 350 | 51.7% | 48.3% | 0.0% | Larger sample | View details |
| #145 | Crites, Elizabeth | Chicago | 686 | 51.6% | 48.4% | 0.0% | Larger sample | View details |
| #146 | Treacy, Elizabeth | Chicago | 483 | 51.5% | 48.5% | 0.0% | Larger sample | View details |
| #147 | Roberts, Lindsy M | Laredo | 879 | 51.5% | 48.5% | 0.0% | Larger sample | View details |
| #148 | Stahl, Marc | Chicago | 1295 | 51.5% | 48.5% | 0.0% | Larger sample | View details |
| #149 | Giambastiani, Jennie L. | Pending | 1373 | 51.5% | 48.5% | 0.0% | Larger sample | View details |
| #150 | Donovan, Mark D | Boston | 575 | 51.5% | 48.5% | 0.0% | Larger sample | View details |
Larger sample
#102
Sady, Michael
Boston
- Total Decisions
- 262
- Asylum Grant Rate
- 57.6%
- Denial Rate
- 42.4%
- Other Relief Rate
- 0.0%
#103
Leadbetter, Philip P.
Pending
- Total Decisions
- 1689
- Asylum Grant Rate
- 57.4%
- Denial Rate
- 42.6%
- Other Relief Rate
- 0.0%
#104
Slavin, Denise N.
Pending
- Total Decisions
- 3605
- Asylum Grant Rate
- 57.1%
- Denial Rate
- 42.9%
- Other Relief Rate
- 0.0%
#105
Koppenhofer, Andrea
Miami
- Total Decisions
- 416
- Asylum Grant Rate
- 57.0%
- Denial Rate
- 43.0%
- Other Relief Rate
- 0.0%
#106
McDermott, William
Philadelphia
- Total Decisions
- 802
- Asylum Grant Rate
- 56.9%
- Denial Rate
- 43.1%
- Other Relief Rate
- 0.0%
#107
McFarland, Michael G
Miami
- Total Decisions
- 1628
- Asylum Grant Rate
- 56.7%
- Denial Rate
- 43.3%
- Other Relief Rate
- 0.0%
#108
O'Malley, Brenda
Pending
- Total Decisions
- 2238
- Asylum Grant Rate
- 56.5%
- Denial Rate
- 43.5%
- Other Relief Rate
- 0.0%
#109
Lyons, Joren
Portland
- Total Decisions
- 1189
- Asylum Grant Rate
- 56.4%
- Denial Rate
- 43.6%
- Other Relief Rate
- 0.0%
#110
Dandelet, Kyle
Miami
- Total Decisions
- 1108
- Asylum Grant Rate
- 56.1%
- Denial Rate
- 43.9%
- Other Relief Rate
- 0.0%
#111
Rohan, Patricia A.
Pending
- Total Decisions
- 8755
- Asylum Grant Rate
- 56.1%
- Denial Rate
- 43.9%
- Other Relief Rate
- 0.0%
#112
Gonzalez, Alberto E.
Pending
- Total Decisions
- 1642
- Asylum Grant Rate
- 56.0%
- Denial Rate
- 44.0%
- Other Relief Rate
- 0.0%
#113
Levay, Dean A.
Pending
- Total Decisions
- 286
- Asylum Grant Rate
- 55.9%
- Denial Rate
- 44.1%
- Other Relief Rate
- 0.0%
#114
Rey Caldas, Carmen
Miami
- Total Decisions
- 286
- Asylum Grant Rate
- 55.9%
- Denial Rate
- 44.1%
- Other Relief Rate
- 0.0%
#115
Patti, Sebastian T
Laredo
- Total Decisions
- 897
- Asylum Grant Rate
- 55.9%
- Denial Rate
- 44.1%
- Other Relief Rate
- 0.0%
#116
Alexander, Erin
Sterling
- Total Decisions
- 328
- Asylum Grant Rate
- 55.8%
- Denial Rate
- 44.2%
- Other Relief Rate
- 0.0%
#117
Proctor, George W.
Pending
- Total Decisions
- 565
- Asylum Grant Rate
- 55.8%
- Denial Rate
- 44.3%
- Other Relief Rate
- 0.0%
#118
Poczter, Aviva L
Miami
- Total Decisions
- 3561
- Asylum Grant Rate
- 55.6%
- Denial Rate
- 44.4%
- Other Relief Rate
- 0.0%
#119
Phan, Susan
Sacramento
- Total Decisions
- 2250
- Asylum Grant Rate
- 55.5%
- Denial Rate
- 44.5%
- Other Relief Rate
- 0.0%
#120
Billings, Lucy
Miami
- Total Decisions
- 295
- Asylum Grant Rate
- 55.3%
- Denial Rate
- 44.8%
- Other Relief Rate
- 0.0%
#121
Zuniga, Bertha A.
Pending
- Total Decisions
- 817
- Asylum Grant Rate
- 55.2%
- Denial Rate
- 44.8%
- Other Relief Rate
- 0.0%
#122
Knuck, Richard H.
Pending
- Total Decisions
- 299
- Asylum Grant Rate
- 55.2%
- Denial Rate
- 44.8%
- Other Relief Rate
- 0.0%
#123
Snow, Thomas G
Arlington
- Total Decisions
- 2000
- Asylum Grant Rate
- 54.8%
- Denial Rate
- 45.2%
- Other Relief Rate
- 0.0%
#124
Gambill, Scott D
Sacramento
- Total Decisions
- 1288
- Asylum Grant Rate
- 54.5%
- Denial Rate
- 45.5%
- Other Relief Rate
- 0.0%
#125
Star, Shadee M
Sacramento
- Total Decisions
- 1260
- Asylum Grant Rate
- 54.4%
- Denial Rate
- 45.6%
- Other Relief Rate
- 0.0%
#126
Feder, Robin E
Honolulu
- Total Decisions
- 1870
- Asylum Grant Rate
- 54.3%
- Denial Rate
- 45.7%
- Other Relief Rate
- 0.0%
#127
Munoz, Jeffrey V
Imperial
- Total Decisions
- 461
- Asylum Grant Rate
- 54.2%
- Denial Rate
- 45.8%
- Other Relief Rate
- 0.0%
#128
Trujillo, Eileen R
Denver
- Total Decisions
- 995
- Asylum Grant Rate
- 53.8%
- Denial Rate
- 46.2%
- Other Relief Rate
- 0.0%
#129
Rosche, Robin J
Chicago
- Total Decisions
- 790
- Asylum Grant Rate
- 53.7%
- Denial Rate
- 46.3%
- Other Relief Rate
- 0.0%
#130
Dornell, Lisa
Pending
- Total Decisions
- 3889
- Asylum Grant Rate
- 53.7%
- Denial Rate
- 46.3%
- Other Relief Rate
- 0.0%
#131
Burr, Sarah M.
Pending
- Total Decisions
- 4532
- Asylum Grant Rate
- 53.6%
- Denial Rate
- 46.4%
- Other Relief Rate
- 0.0%
#132
Elstein, Annette S.
Pending
- Total Decisions
- 5559
- Asylum Grant Rate
- 53.5%
- Denial Rate
- 46.5%
- Other Relief Rate
- 0.0%
#133
Weiss, Irene
Pending
- Total Decisions
- 1490
- Asylum Grant Rate
- 53.1%
- Denial Rate
- 46.9%
- Other Relief Rate
- 0.0%
#134
Kirchner, Steven M
Sacramento
- Total Decisions
- 1549
- Asylum Grant Rate
- 52.9%
- Denial Rate
- 47.1%
- Other Relief Rate
- 0.0%
#135
Figueroa, Laura C
Sacramento
- Total Decisions
- 1140
- Asylum Grant Rate
- 52.8%
- Denial Rate
- 47.2%
- Other Relief Rate
- 0.0%
#136
Harbeck, Dorothy A
Miami
- Total Decisions
- 1967
- Asylum Grant Rate
- 52.6%
- Denial Rate
- 47.4%
- Other Relief Rate
- 0.0%
#137
Stender, Jacob J
Sacramento
- Total Decisions
- 542
- Asylum Grant Rate
- 52.6%
- Denial Rate
- 47.4%
- Other Relief Rate
- 0.0%
#138
Wilson, Roberta A
Concord
- Total Decisions
- 564
- Asylum Grant Rate
- 52.5%
- Denial Rate
- 47.5%
- Other Relief Rate
- 0.0%
#139
Webber, Polly A.
Pending
- Total Decisions
- 2728
- Asylum Grant Rate
- 52.3%
- Denial Rate
- 47.7%
- Other Relief Rate
- 0.0%
#140
Gover, Erin
Boston
- Total Decisions
- 729
- Asylum Grant Rate
- 52.3%
- Denial Rate
- 47.7%
- Other Relief Rate
- 0.0%
#141
Gagnon, Paul M.
Pending
- Total Decisions
- 1442
- Asylum Grant Rate
- 52.1%
- Denial Rate
- 47.9%
- Other Relief Rate
- 0.0%
#142
Crawford, Carol A
Miami
- Total Decisions
- 767
- Asylum Grant Rate
- 52.0%
- Denial Rate
- 48.0%
- Other Relief Rate
- 0.0%
#143
Joyce, William
Pending
- Total Decisions
- 639
- Asylum Grant Rate
- 52.0%
- Denial Rate
- 48.0%
- Other Relief Rate
- 0.0%
#144
Hong, J. Traci
Pending
- Total Decisions
- 350
- Asylum Grant Rate
- 51.7%
- Denial Rate
- 48.3%
- Other Relief Rate
- 0.0%
#145
Crites, Elizabeth
Chicago
- Total Decisions
- 686
- Asylum Grant Rate
- 51.6%
- Denial Rate
- 48.4%
- Other Relief Rate
- 0.0%
#146
Treacy, Elizabeth
Chicago
- Total Decisions
- 483
- Asylum Grant Rate
- 51.5%
- Denial Rate
- 48.5%
- Other Relief Rate
- 0.0%
#147
Roberts, Lindsy M
Laredo
- Total Decisions
- 879
- Asylum Grant Rate
- 51.5%
- Denial Rate
- 48.5%
- Other Relief Rate
- 0.0%
#148
Stahl, Marc
Chicago
- Total Decisions
- 1295
- Asylum Grant Rate
- 51.5%
- Denial Rate
- 48.5%
- Other Relief Rate
- 0.0%
#149
Giambastiani, Jennie L.
Pending
- Total Decisions
- 1373
- Asylum Grant Rate
- 51.5%
- Denial Rate
- 48.5%
- Other Relief Rate
- 0.0%
#150
Donovan, Mark D
Boston
- Total Decisions
- 575
- Asylum Grant Rate
- 51.5%
- Denial Rate
- 48.5%
- Other Relief Rate
- 0.0%
This website is for general information only and is not legal advice.