Immigration Judge

Martz, Nicholas A

Assigned court
Oakdale
Status
active

Total Decisions

144

Asylum Grant Rate

22.9%

Asylum grants: 33

Denial Rate

75.0%

Denials: 108

Other Relief Rate

2.1%

Other Relief: 3

Public Data

Asylum grants33 / 144
Denials108 / 144
Other Relief3 / 144

Sample Size Note

The sample size is relatively substantial, but it still cannot predict any individual case outcome.

Nationality-specific statistics

NationalityTotal decisionsGrant rateDenial rate
MEXICO940.0%100.0%View details
CUBA8821.6%78.4%View details
EL SALVADOR8211.0%89.0%View details
HONDURAS600.0%100.0%View details
VENEZUELA553.6%96.4%View details

Data Source

Data Source
TRAC Immigration Judge Reports
Publisher
TRAC Immigration
Reporting Period
Pending - Pending
Updated by this site
Jul 7, 2026

Other judges at the same immigration court

Ashworth, Sherron

Status: active

Asylum Grant Rate
10.0%
Denial Rate
85.3%
View details

Bashore, Jacob D

Status: active

Asylum Grant Rate
7.5%
Denial Rate
89.0%
View details

Baumgarten, Mary C

Status: active

Asylum Grant Rate
29.0%
Denial Rate
56.0%
View details

Duck, John A., Jr

Status: active

Asylum Grant Rate
17.9%
Denial Rate
79.8%
View details

Eller, Donald R., Jr

Status: active

Asylum Grant Rate
8.1%
Denial Rate
90.5%
View details

Espinal, Pedro J

Status: active

Asylum Grant Rate
53.1%
Denial Rate
44.6%
View details
Disclaimer

This website is for general information only and is not legal advice.