Immigration Judge

McCarthy, James F., III

Assigned court
Cleveland
Status
active

Total Decisions

103

Asylum Grant Rate

11.7%

Asylum grants: 12

Denial Rate

86.4%

Denials: 89

Other Relief Rate

1.9%

Other Relief: 2

Public Data

Asylum grants12 / 103
Denials89 / 103
Other Relief2 / 103

Sample Size Note

The sample size is relatively substantial, but it still cannot predict any individual case outcome.

Data Source

Data Source
TRAC Immigration Judge Reports
Publisher
TRAC Immigration
Reporting Period
Pending - Pending
Updated by this site
Jul 6, 2026

Other judges at the same immigration court

Burke, Patrick

Status: active

Asylum Grant Rate
9.8%
Denial Rate
87.9%
View details

Horton, Monte J

Status: active

Asylum Grant Rate
18.3%
Denial Rate
75.9%
View details

Owens, Jonathan W

Status: active

Asylum Grant Rate
22.7%
Denial Rate
72.3%
View details

Pashayan, Donald

Status: active

Asylum Grant Rate
17.5%
Denial Rate
77.1%
View details

Riedthaler-Williams, Jennifer M

Status: active

Asylum Grant Rate
16.8%
Denial Rate
78.2%
View details

Riley, Teresa L

Status: active

Asylum Grant Rate
15.3%
Denial Rate
81.0%
View details
Disclaimer

This website is for general information only and is not legal advice.